I have been thinking a lot about this distinction recently, that is the fundamental shift in thinking that others are not simply competitors to be beaten but are teammates to be celebrated and joined.
I do not think this is a natural position to take in our world right now. I mean, if I, a very idealistic, well-intentioned, pseudo anarchist Catholic Worker type, have a hard time fighting the urge to compete with others, what is the likelihood that your average Joe in the world of business or medicine or law or whatever, isn’t having this urge like times a thousand? Because frankly, it is a very human position to feel that in a world of scarce resources, we have to look out for #1.
The saints provide a beautiful counterpoint to this position. There are very few, okay probably zero, saints who pushed their way to the top of sanctity, who “climbed the ladder” of virtue at the expense of others. We celebrated Dorothy Day’s feast day yesterday and Saint Andrew’s feast day today. These were two people who joined, who entered INto community and did not try to compete once they were in. Andrew was the fisherman who invited Peter to come and see, and then spent the rest of his life inviting others in. Dorothy was the friend of the poor worker who made room for the stranger, even in her own bed.
Because that’s how the spiritual life works. Maybe in the world of food and money and power and authority there are limited spots, limited resources. But in the reality of the Spirit, there is a different economy that is genuinely the opposite of the physical realm in this sense. The more love you give away, the more love you receive. The more joy you experience, the more joy another can experience too. The more sadness we bear with one another, the less sadness there will be. The more we team up with those on the fringe, the outcasts, the fewer “teams” there will be and the more we will see everyone as on the same team.
I often write about Sheila McCarthy because she is a really good example of a lot of things in the Good Life around Saint Joseph Street. And her journey to finishing her dissertation is no exception.
I hear from many graduate students about the crazy competition for so few job openings exist in the Academy. I hear about the lack of collaboration and the tendency to go rogue in order to set yourself apart in your field. This is basically the opposite to Sheila’s approach to her PhD.
Sheila sees her life as an academic as secondary to her life as a Catholic Worker and friend to the downtrodden (as well as the whole and the happy). She is a great friend to many people of all stripes, and so when she is in need, she confidently turns to her friends for help. The time has come for her to FINISH her PhD, a milestone I never thought would occur (why am I such a naysayer? She’s done everything else she’s ever set out to do), and so she’s turned to others to help her do this.
I do not have my PhD, and I have never written a dissertation, therefore I have absolutely no grounds to make the following statement (besides watching my friends in their grueling journey). Writing a dissertation is like swimming across a really big lake wearing jeans and a sweatshirt. And it’s foggy so you can’t see the other side. And there might be sharks.
But Sheila’s approach, that is asking her friends to coach her each week, to take on her goals with her and to help keep her disciplined, fed, exercised and prayed, is like asking for help and having someone(s) break through the fog and pull you into a row boat and hand you the oars. And some hot chocolate and a blanket. Now you don’t have to swim, sodden and exhausted, by yourself across an unknown distance. You have someone in the boat with you, and it’s actually kind of fun.
John and I were Sheila’s coaches this week. Between the three of us we went to daily Mass, ate delicious paninis and dark chocolate in the library, did push ups, went on runs, and generally had a great time. And I think Sheila got a lot of writing done. It was a very refreshing approach that made me think a lot about collaboration. We helped each other be better people. We pushed each other to be more disciplined, more faithful and more healthy than we would have been otherwise. That’s pretty amazing. And there was, like, zero sense of competition. Just encouragement, affirmation, and hope.
I’ve decided I need some life coaching. And I want to return the favor. I would like my friendships to look more like our coaching week with Sheila and less like the comparing and competing I sometimes feel from myself and my truly wonderful friends. It is always tempting to compare, to feel less because someone else is more, but Sheila taught me this week that we are ALL MORE when one of us is more, we just have to invite the others in. Are you in?